BlogMatrix
 

Maybe the book was just bad?

edit secondgenerationradical 2008-08-09 00:31 UTC add comment  ·  ·

I am not one to 'blow my own horn", but Chapters lawyer in one of the pre-trial motions made some snide comment about the book, so I thought that, for the record, I would post some brief excerpts from reviews to get this issue out of the way.

The book is perhaps not great literature, but it does have something important to say, and the fact that it was banned without the civil liberties people and authors' organizations objecting tells us a lot.

Praise for The Second Catastrophe:  A Novel about a Book and its Author

 

“The Second Catastrophe is a compelling read”

- David Solway, author of author of The Big Lie: On Terror, Antisemitism, and Identity

 

“sounds a profound and striking note of alarm…Rotberg has done his research and added human emotions and frailties so that readers are both moved by the drama and informed by his global perspective”

- Cynthia Gasner, Canadian Jewish News

 

“an uncompromising and deeply disturbing political and historical study of the threat to the Jewish people today… the undeniable power of this book … is that once you read it, you will never again watch the TV news, or read a headline about the Middle East, in the same way.”

- Luisa D’Amato, The Record (Kitchener-Waterloo)

 

“a charming and heartbreaking pro-Israel story”

- Phyllis Chesler, author of The New Anti-Semitism

 

 

 

 

Fighting Islamist Intimidation and the "submission" of Chapters/Heather Reisman

edit secondgenerationradical 2008-08-04 23:00 UTC 2 comments  ·  ·  ·  ·

A huge problem that I had for many many months after Chapters in a press release said that I made "racist" statements,was the following:   Chapters refused to put in writing just what I am alleged to have said to justify their actions of calling me a “racist”, etc.  They refused to do this, even though the Court ordered them to disclose this by a certain date, which they failed to do, and I had to push them in the court proceedings to finally release the written statements of the employee or employees upon which they based their press release.   The obvious reason that they refused for so long was that in fact I did not say anything at all “racist”.  In addition, they made the allegation BEFORE they had any written statements at all - they were in such a rush to submit to the Islamist intimidation of an 18 year old part time employee.  My biggest problem then was in this Orwellian world I was fighting against an allegation which, although made, and which, while extremely prejudicial in this cultural climate, did not even have to be disclosed to me.  It is almost a secret trial, where Judge Heather Reisman  decided I am a racist, and the entire Jewish community, and civil rights community, and the intellectual Left, are prepared to accept that. With very few exceptions (the wonderful Canadian Coalition for Democracies, and the Mackenzie Institute) I couldn't  get any organization to help fight this “chilling” McCarthyism of the Left.

I fear that this is in fact a type of McCarthyism where instead of witchhunts against Communist sympathizers, we are out to shun Israel sympathizers, and anyone who dares voice concern over cultural problems in the Arab world, especially in radical Islam.   It is hard enough to exercise freedom of speech when your “unpopular” opinions expose you to physical intimidation, but when you can’t get any backing or support, it becomes a “martyr’s” game.

For a long time I tried to get the Waterloo police department to charge the Islamist hecklers who broke up the lecture, with "causing a disturbance".   I wasn't asking them to charge them with a hate crime, although it would have been appropriate.  I thought causing a disturbance would be an easy charge to make stick.   Not only did they refuse, one detective eventually told me to stop bothering them, or she might charge me! (with what, I don't know)

I thought if I could get Canadian Jewish Congress or the Wiesenthal Centre to make a formal request to lay charges, the police might take this more seriously.    I was so disappointed that none of them would pick up the phone or send a letter or email, I was quoted in the Canadian Jewish News stating the obvious - that it would have helped if some Jewish organization had been willing to help.  Ths statement obviously irked Bernie Farber the Executive Director of the Canadian Jewish Congress, so he decided to put me in my place:   he said he had no idea what happened at the Chapters (although I offered him sworn affidavits from witnesses) and that he had "every confidence" in the Waterloo Police Department.   That kind of despicable attitude reminded me of the Jewish Councils during the Holocaust.

I feel that only now, after 4 years, with the trial upcoming, and the country waking up to the "lawfare" against Levant and Steyn, are people waking up to what happened to me, and what it means.   The internet is a big help when established media (even the National Post) wouldn't cover the story.

One other problem is that certain Jews who own or manage big media or bookstores, live with a pathetic attitude of fear that anti-Semites will see them as proof that the Jews control the media, or this or that.   Submitting to your anti-semitic critics is a pitiful sight, and one wonders what good all the money, prestige and power is doing, if they have to be so fearful and so submissive.


If you look at the written statement of Ms. Al-Halimi, it is quite clear that allegations of racism are used as a weapon against those who are firstly, perceived to hold the "wrong" opinion about some ideological, political, or religious issue, and, secondly, are in a position of greater (perceived) power, since "racism" has been redefined by some evil academics as relating only to those situations where there is a power differential.

Here, again is the written statement of Al-Halimi, and notice how little it has to do with the facts, and how much it has to do with what she thinks I must think of her.

Read this carefully, as it tells us a lot about what are we are facing when Canada's monopoly book retailer puts enough confidence in this statement to ban my books.  And note how she ends her rant with the chilling lines that what I must have thought about her amounts to "racism at its worst".....You can imagine how I feel, when I lost my grandparents and aunt to the gas chambers for the crime of being Jewish, that I now find out that what I did at Chapters was in fact "racism at its worst" by this young girl but more importantly by Canada's monopoly book retailer.   And note please that I in no way said "All Middle Eastern people are terrorists" or anything close to that.   And note the irony that my novel is about a professor who gets in trouble after giving a lecture:


“ I went to see the author signing fifteen minutes into it and when I got closer to the area, I heard voices that became louder and louder.  I saw two people in the audience, one calmly stating basic facts to the author, the other yelling out, ‘What are you … a f***ing Jew?’ only to have the author yell back, ‘A f***ing Jew?  This only proves that Middle Eastern people are terrorists.’  From there the yelling progressed, eventually reaching a point where the managers asked the audience members to leave, and the author gave up and stepped into their office.

“For a person to come into my workplace and insult and judge me in such a manner without him knowing anything about me is absurd.   According to him, when walking down the street, I should be avoided at all times because my skin is darker and I wear a headscarf.  I am aware that the man in the audience should not have cursed at all given the atmosphere. Nonetheless, the author, as a professional and as a representative of what books the company holds should have controlled himself against saying such piercing words.  It was uncalled for, rude and worst of all it was racial discrimination.

“What frustrates me most about this whole scenario is the fact that both customers and employees alike had to witness something so hateful towards those of Middle Eastern descent.  At one of the most difficult times to be of a visible minority for Arab and Muslim people, it was completely unjust for him to generalize the way that he did.  I also noticed that he kept repeating the word ‘they’ and ‘them’ like we were some vicious robots that act, think and speak alike with one brain. Even if it was for a split second that someone looked at me and thought, ‘So she’s a terrorist?’ that is one split second too much.  I have never in my life done anything to intentionally hurt anyone, and to be accused of being one that intentionally inflicts pain upon others is hurtful and untrue.  It seems as if my genetic makeup caused him to automatically make an unfair assumption.  And that is racism at its worst.”


- Written statement of Raneem Al-Halimi, part time employee at Waterloo Chapters.